Friday, 3 February 2017

Thoughts on text-mining and intertext


Friends, Romans, countrymen: why haven’t we built a text-mining tool to facilitate one of our favourite occupations within the field, namely the spotting of intertext?

Most of the time, I imagine most of us establish intertext by dint of knowing the one (or two, or three) author(s) of our specialisms extremely well – well enough that certain phrases may trigger our recognition so that we connect the two. Sometimes the idea of intertext has to be discarded if no meaningful engagement can be argued; sometimes we craft entire articles around what the allusion by one author to the words of another can mean. I’m not saying there is anything wrong with this. What I am wondering is whether we are missing opportunities.

The current approach produces results which, though valid in the individual instances they are establishing, cannot say anything about the extent of borrowing and engagement between two authors more widely. We may recognize, if we know our Plautus well, a Ciceronian borrowing of him in a particular speech that we’re working on, but there it ends. Is it the only speech in which he engages with Plautus? Does he do this frequently? Does he draw on some passages or works more than others? Does he borrow from Plautus, and within that from particular works, more than he borrows from other authors which predate him? The questions are much more difficult to answer without a deep and long immersion in both texts, with no guarantee of further results. (I’m not saying this would be ‘wasted’ time in the absence of results, but within the current realities of academic knowledge production and career assessment, time must to a certain extent ‘pay off’.)

People have written theses around constructing these sorts of relationships on the basis of individual occurrences, and may even in recent years have started feeding their authors of choice into text parsing programmes to help with the work, but the results are still limited to a pre-selected set of authors which we either know well or suspect of such intertextual engagement, and therefore informed by our bias and expectations from the beginning.

So why can’t we build a database tool that makes connections across all of Latin literature, and then select from the results what strikes us as interesting? Granted, it would throw up a lot that is misleading or of no use on account of being meaningless -- fixed expressions being one of the obvious pitfalls (if 80% of authors from 3rd century BC Plautus to 4th century AD Ausonius used the phrase ‘getting up at the crack of dawn’ we can probably safely discard the possibility of intertext between them all). But by widening the net I suspect we would notice a lot that no one has before, simply because not many of us are sufficiently closely conversant with more than a handful of authors or texts in the course of our lifetimes. We would also eliminate the possibility that we’d just ‘missed’ stuff, even within our own field of expertise.

What I would greatly enjoy using, should it ever exist, would be an online data-churning resource for the entire body of Latin classical texts (yes, the chronological parameters would require some thinking) which compares syntax and vocab across these texts and flags up passages of similarity, possibly with a percentage indicator judging how great the overlap is. There are already programmes designed to flag up plagiarism, such as CrossCheck/iThenticate, which do similar things. I never dealt with them much during my time in publishing, nor with Turnitin in my academic teaching so far, so sadly I don’t know much about the detail.

Of course these programmes operate slightly differently: you put in a chunk of text, say a submitted journal article or a student’s work, and the programme compares this chunk to the whole body of articles in its database. But even if we simply copied this format, this would already be extremely useful for classical scholars who, as I said above, still start from a point where they pre-select the material they’d like to work with.

After all, I know of no projects centered around questions as broad as ‘let’s see what comes up if we compare everthing ever’. I suspect the processing power required to do this, depending on the database size, would be too much, and building an intelligible and user-friendly interface for viewing the results would be impossible. But ‘let’s see what comes up if I copy and paste Tacitus’ description of the battlefield of the Varian disaster in the Teutoburgerwald’ would already produce wider-reaching results than the human mind is capable of and I, for one, would be extremely interested in seeing them. They machine would not draw your conclusions for you, but you could get straight to the interpreting without having to slosh through the data in a human, and thus flawed, manner.

(Amusingly, about a year ago I was at my funder the AHRC’s annual skills training conference, about which I blogged here. I remember having a conversation with an artist from Falmouth named Dane Watkins at the time, who had an interest in such things and told me that as I was already doing some of this stuff anyway (as indeed I was, in the third chapter of my thesis, which I actually wrote first and must have told him about at the time) I should do it more systematically. I wish I remembered more of the conversation, but it clearly didn’t prompt me into action or even serious consideration at the time.)

So why doesn’t this kind of resource exist yet? I’ve had a long old think about this, and I think it’s possible to split the reasons into the two broad categories of ‘technical’ and ‘emotional’.

Classicists don’t tend to be techies. As a species we are not educated into becoming masters of digital skills, but into linguists, historians, translators, and critical thinkers in a way which has not so far required any (or not much) external mediation between us and our source material. With the advent of Digital Humanities thankfully many people have woken up to the possibilities and importance of IT to the field, with lovely results such as my personal favourites ORBIS or PHI Latin Texts. Though pretty low-grade in its looks (I don’t know about the back-end), I am also rather fond of the texts on Perseus, as well as its dictionary and word study tools. The most exciting one of all that I’ve come across is Diogenes, made by classics scholar and digital humanist Dr P. J. Heslin at the University of Durham, which draws on various other databases of classical texts to allow for rather complicated searching, such as (in Dr Heslin’s own example from this talk) all possible declensions of the word ‘Caesar’ in the works of Cicero, or only certain declensions of the word ‘Athena’ in texts marked in the database as belonging to the genre ‘epic’. What I can’t ascertain at the moment, because I don’t yet understand how to use the thing, is whether it is set up to do what I have outlined above, even though that seems to me to be only a moderate expansion of what it already seems to do.

So why haven’t we gone for full-on text-mining, given that there are some of us who have the technical skills and others who do not have clearly found suitable partners to help them build things? This brings me to the ‘emotional’ reasons.

I’ve already said we do intertext all the time, and we like making connections. Is there, however, some unspoken or even unconscious feeling that these things should be spotted through hard graft rather than automated comparison? Do we feel it's somehow at odds with the literary nature of these texts? Does it demean their art to involve a level of automation in our engagement with them? Do we fear it may undermine past research on intertextual connections which have been argued to be unique but may in fact occur elsewhere, in authors one doesn't happen to be familiar with or interested in? Do we think it would throw up too much that is irrelevant so that it would be too labour-intensive to use? Have others had this idea (I struggle to imagine they haven’t) but haven't had the time, money, inclination, technical skills, right contacts to pursue it? Is someone somewhere already working on this in silence?

Or is it because we like our current method of selecting the direction of our research before starting it, as opposed to seeing what the data throws up and then selecting what we'd like to get our teeth into? Would narrowing down what to follow up on be too difficult? An admittedly quick google (but, in fact, on DuckDuckGo, because they don’t track your searches) on text mining in the humanities threw up only these two examples, on text mining ancient Chinese medical literature and classical music scores.

Why are we not doing this? (If we are, please tell me.)

IT savvy friends have assured me that it wouldn’t be very difficult at all to build such a data-churning tool. Much of our raw data is already out there in digital form (Perseus has most of current Latin literature texts uploaded, as does PHI, as does even a bare-bones, quick-reference resource such as The Latin Library), and it’s not as if we have to worry about copyright.

I imagine the fact that Latin is a declined language could be a bit of a problem, but there must be ways round that. Texts on Perseus, for example, are coded so that if you click on any word in the Latin text it will take you through to a list identifying the word’s morphology. Which means the back end of the resource recognizes word stems and dictionary entry forms as well as their possible modifications when declined or conjugated. It would have to be explored whether building a supra-engine for text mining which drew on the databases of these already existing resources and their databases is possible and whether the institutions which host them would give permission, or under what conditions/for what remuneration they would do so. The Diogenes ‘Thanks’ page refers to Perseus’ Creative Commons licencing which has allowed Dr Heslin to draw on their database, so again I can’t imagine it would be very hard.

If sufficient collaborations could not be established, having to duplicate the data entry work would be a disadvantage in terms of the time and money required to set it up. But at the same time a resource not reliant on the others’ continued hosting of compatible (!) databases into the future would have the advantage of complete control over both its future and its design. A newbuild could make its coding open source and its licencing format CC-BY-NC, allowing others to borrow (for example for other fields of literature), but not for commercial purposes.

Techie people with a classics background must be hard to find, so there would still be a large and important role for classical ‘editors’ to test successive developments of the resource in order to help refine the rules which determine results so that the output would be as accurate and relevant as possible. Presumably, they’d also need to have people on hand to explain to them, nevermind to the programme, how Latin actually works.

Is this the stuff that postdocs are made of?

I need to do more research and then have a long hard think. But really, I need to get on and write the fourth chapter of my thesis.

(**The answer to the question of how I came to have these thoughts is longer and less interesting than these loose thoughts, but briefly: a Tacitean passage I’m working on struck me as very Caesarian in ‘feel’. Leaving aside the difficulty of establishing which criteria to adopt in order to potentially verify this, I also realized that I didn’t have the time to get to know Caesar as well as I do Tacitus during the scope of my current project, and this led me to think of the idea of the digital tool I am ruminating on in this blog post.**)

Wednesday, 25 January 2017

Women's Classical Committee Wikipedia Editathon - 23 January 2017

My most recent (but not so recent) blog post, you may remember, was to do with the Women's Classical Committee. It's an organisation of recent standing which does marvellous work in pursuit of admirable aims, with the heartening support of all possible genders. Though I'm not good enough with crowds and unfamiliar places to have felt comfortable joining the Women's March in London this Saturday just past, I like to think I made a small gesture, but a practical as well as a symbolic one, towards equal representation by attending the WCC's all-day Wikipedia editathon at Senate House in London.

The idea was to go some way towards redressing the gender imbalance in notable classicists' Wikipedia profiles: before Monday, about 20 out of 200 biographical pages were of women. During the event, each of us picked an un- or underrepresented woman (**) to work on that afternoon after the morning's training, so that by the end of the day we'd added 12, which is around 6%. A small but significant jump. You can find the project page here.

(** by 'under' I mean either already existing as a stub or as a 'red link' on another page, which is a passing mention without a page of one's own)

The lady I chose was Dr Miriam Tamara Griffin, because she's a great classical scholar (of Nero, the Julio-Claudians more generally, and Seneca -- as well as various other things) who on Wikipedia was no more than a dead link in her famous classics professor husband's profile. Now in her early eighties, she was also real Oxford trailblazer in terms of being a female academic in classics. She deserves recognition for both her scholarly output and the trailblazing! You can find the page I made here.

And here's a video of Dr Ellie Mackin (Twitter @EllieMackin) of Leicester and me, discussing why the event felt so valuable for us and how we see it impacting on what we might do in the future:


To round off, therefore, a big and well-deserved shout out to the organisers of the event, Claire Millington (Twitter @Claire_M) at KCL and Emma Bridges of the Open University (Twitter @emmabridges), as well as to the Wikimedia UK paid staff (Richard Nevell and somebody called John whose surname I unfortunately didn't catch), ably supported by volunteers Roberta, Kelly and Andrew, for the training and support provided. Wikipedia has more procedural and content rules than you would imagine, so the guidance is not only welcome but even to this fairly technically literate person seemed welcome. Personally I love a bit of low-level coding, and Wikipedia's is so low you probably can't even call it that, but for those who don't there is a visual editor that looks a little like a word processing programme to help you write and mark up your post (not unlike Blogger, in which I am writing this post, in fact). No, the real challenge is what you can and can't say, how you can or can't say it, and what counts as sufficient evidence to back it up. For photographs, you get into the territory of licensing arrangements, and that can get tricky too. Dr Griffin was kind enough to email me a photograph to put up on her Wikipedia page, so you'd think this would be an easy one, but this too seems to come with its own set of problems, which I am still trying to work out how to solve. Or more accurately: the uploading itself will be simple, but assuring Wikipedia and its real and bot-shaped editors that it's ok for the photo to be up there will be a different matter. Watch not this space, therefore, but this one.

And finally, a postscript, for those not yet bored of reading... I'm including this because I'm as happy to expose what I think is male bias, however unconscious, as I am to expose myself to the disagreement of others on this matter. On the very day of my Wikipedia initiation, I also made my first foray into the territory of 'edit wars' (or at least, the temptation to start one...). By the time I had travelled from the pub near Russell Square to the coach stop at Baker Street, I already had a notification from Wikipedia that my profile had been 'checked', and approved by someone, subject to some edits. These edits were: the removal of the word 'distinguished' in the introductory sentence, which had said 'Miriam Tamara Griffin is a distinguished American classical scholar', as well as the removal of the words 'long and distinguished' from a sentence talking about the Festschrift she had dedicated to her in 2002 in recognition of her, indeed, long and distinguished career. In both cases the adjectives were removed as being 'subjective'. In view of Wikipedia's criteria of notability for academics, this felt to me as if she passed the notability test but I wasn't allowed to say so. (Incidentally, in the case of the subjects we worked on on Monday, the notability test is in itself arguably sexist: much is made of named professorships, international awards, chairmanships of organisations, etc., exactly the sorts of posts from which these first-wave 20th century female scholars were habitually excluded for a long time. I know they've listed other reasons, and you only need one, but the list seems to be made without any awareness of this historical background for academics specifically.) More importantly, though, I was amazed that a demonstrable career of 50+ years which the article was obviously outlining could not be called objectively 'long', and that the dedicatee of a Festschrift with Oxford University Press could not objectively said to have had a distinguished career. A Festschrift is, surely, by its very nature, a recognition of someone's.... long and distinguished career! But ho hum. That's by the by...

Monday, 26 September 2016

Women's Classical Committee (WCC) launch event (11 April 2016)

So it turns out I didn't write up any notes in a blog draft shortly after this event (from APRIL), possibly because the room in which the conference was held was unfortunately very hot and I had to rush off to avoid getting properly unwell. Then I had to get on a Eurostar quite early the next day, and once I saw my niece and nephews all else fell by the wayside. (Other than my self-reflective essay for teacher training, which took a long time but paid off in the form of a special commendation from the inSTIL programme team!)

First things first: what is the WCC? It self-identifies admirably clearly on its website as an organisation which aims (hah) to achieve the following aims:

- Support women* in classics**
- Promote feminist and gender-informed perspectives in classics
- Raise the profile of the study of women in antiquity and classical reception
- Advance equality and diversity in classics

Basically, anyone is welcome, other than the silly man who complained to a female archaeologist friend that he couldn't join the Women's Digital Archaeology Network because where is the equality in that? You're out. (And if you're that blind to the historical power imbalance along gendered lines, you may want to consider getting the hell out of this type of field.)

I have left in the asterisks in their aims, which lead respectively to a wonderful acknowledgement of the irrelevance of a biological basis for womanhood compared to self-definition and a usefully broad and realistic definition of the field of classics. This is a sign, y'all, of not just how politically correct this organisation wishes to be but, apolitically speaking, how HUMAN it is. I'm particularly proud to have attended the event, to have helped out a little in doing preliminary research for its membership structure, and of course to be a member, given the pivotal role of my 2nd thesis advisor Dr Liz Gloyn's involvement in getting this organisation off the ground. You've got to love people who see something admirable somewhere else in the world - in this case, the Women's Classical Caucus in the US, which impressively has its own Wikipedia page - and think 'we need that here!'. And then actually go and DO IT!

(I'm also particularly proud of Liz's awesomeness with regard to gender-related stuff, given that she's just been slated by the execrable Daily Mail - much as I hate to add to their page views, here is the article - for notifying the students on her Ovid course in advance that there is some nasty stuff in those texts, like domestic abuse and rape. She's written more about this here. In addition to the DM's painting this as nannying when campus-based gendered violence and rape is so prominent yet so not taken seriously, another bad thing about the article is that it ends on a sentence that suggests that if you're going to take a course on classical literature and have zero prior knowledge of it, then OF COURSE your default expectation must be to expect rape and pillaging left, right and centre. There are actually some beautiful texts from antiquity that give you hope for the human race, turds-at-the-DM!)

But! Back to the event. As said, this was an inaugural event so the whole day demonstrated an incredible variety of points of view and ways of expressing them and of engaging with each other. You can access the livetweeting through the hashtag wcclaunch and Liz's Storify here, but here are the main things that really stand out in my mind about it (other than the stifling heat in the room :0)

1. The incredibly personal nature of many of the stories shared. I chose to attend a breakout session on mental health, which I realise may therefore not have contained a representative sample of the general PhD population but nonetheless, given the variety of backgrounds, ages, fields, etc. the prevalence of depression in all its varying forms in academia is astounding. And frightening. The prevalence suggests structural causes (assuming we don't believe that only people prone to mental health issues are attracted to academia in the first place, whether masochistically or not - as I don't) but unfortunately I'm not sure what could be done institutionally to remedy this.

Loneliness was identified as a serious cause, though, and the provision of communal space for working in the presence of the likeminded could be a good way forward, I think. I wonder whether any research has been done as to the prevalence of mental health issues in lab-based and therefore less socially deprived PhD students compared to lonely humanities ones without a fixed base?

The community aspect also fed into physical disability, as one attendant of the group in a wheelchair was effectively barred from her own department as it was on the first floor of a building with no lift. Although people are often helpful and try to make arrangements, she has the added burden of having to plan her access needs in a way that people like me do not, and the sacrifice of spontaneity comes at a social cost, I am sure, not to mention the practical challenge of just making sure you can sit in on any meetings, seminars, etc. required. A few days later I spoke to Mai Musié in charge of Oxford's Classics outreach programme, and she said Oxford have actually conducted an audit to identify every single case where something as little-seeming as a single raised step forms an access barrier. I can't remember the details of how quickly everything will come up to scratch, but it's a start. More people need to do this!

2. The presentation of the survey results contained the slight revelation for me (well, I had probably not bothered to give it much thought, let me put it that way) that many of the issues identified weren't applicable to women alone, though for some issues it seemed to be the case that women were disproportionately affected. You can read the committee members' full analysis of the findings here.

From my own perspective, the two main issues directly affecting me negatively in my position - and which are by no means gender-specific! - which fall within the campaign goals of the WCC to improve the lot of women in classics are both ones which boil down to the prevalence of two very specific cases of impossible and contradictory expectations which are held of PhD students:

a) There is a mismatch between the general consensus that PhDs now realistically take four, rather than three, years to complete, and my funder's standard grant of three years' money. Those of us without either trust funds or baby-boomer parents who are both able and willing to help, are seriously hindered by this. There is agreement that it virtually can't be done, yet we are still expected to do it. And not only does this cause psychological anguish, it literally gets us in our pockets. Work while we finish off? Sure, but it's going to slow us down, and in a political climate obsessed with statistics and value for money for the taxpayer, extentions are not granted as enthusiastically as they once were.

b) The mismatch between the academic job market's requirement for you to have publications to your name when you come to apply for posts and on the one hand the impossible time pressure you have to complete your PhD, nevermind have extra time to crack out publications not related to your thesis. This is further exacerbated by college regulations, in some cases including mine, which prohibit PhD researchers from publishing or even submitting to publishers work from their thesis prior to finishing. So anyone who finishes is in the unenviable position of having at least a 9-month period ahead of them, during which they will be looking for work (for which publications are essential) but who are unlikely to have any publications to their name.

Alongside the WCC, another organisation which has identified some of these issues (though not the ones I suffer from specifically) and offers institutions suggestions to mitigate their impact on current students and recent graduates in particular, is Hortensii.

We need people who heed these concerns so very badly. Please add your voice, as it can only make their advocacy and clout with employers and funders stronger.

Tuesday, 23 August 2016

Gateway to the Gods: an ancient temple site at Marcham (Oxfordshire)

So I absolutely haven't blogged for way too long. But when I logged in just now hoping to recap the 9th Celtic Conference in Classics (Dublin, June 2016, hashtag #celtclass) for you, I saw that I had some other ideas lined up and other events to write up. I should probably tackle those first, before I forget.

The first of the ideas was to belatedly (so belatedly it's virtually POSTHUMOUSLY) put down some thoughts on visiting the 'Gateway to the Gods' exhibition on the archaeological digs held from 2001 to 2011 at the Roman temple complex in Marcham near me in Abingdon. On this map go down from Frilford centre, along the A338 until you hit the river Ock. In the top right corner of the cross formed by the road meeting the river is the temple complex:



The exhibition was held across several rooms of the attractively rustic and yet well-run Vale & Downlands Museum in the South Oxfordshire town of Wantage - allegedly the birthplace of King Alfred. There's certainly a statue of him, and a pub named after him, too. I didn't know it was on but we were in Wantage that day anyway for the fantastic second hand book shop, and saw the poster:



The exhibition was quite modest in its scope and setup, which is why six months later I can no longer give you the sorts of details that I would have liked to. However!

The site is apparently was one of the biggest sites of Roman (or was it? probably mixed!) worship in the whole of Roman Britain! That's definitely not nothing. It seems to be a stroke of good luck that much of it is underneath fields (read: the site largely hasn't got modern buildings on them) so digs have been taking place regularly for many years. I find it very interesting how a site's importance in antiquity is no guarantee whatsoever for its importance or continued use or similar use into the present day.

Marcham is known worldwide as the host village (actually, its subvillage of Frilford, but y'know) to local farm shop and petting zoo Millets Farm as well as The Place Where My Parents Put Petrol Into Their Diesel Car In 2007. Incredible what's beneath our feet much of the time, unbeknownst to us.

Anyone who wants to know more can in fact order a small 20-page informational booklet for £2 by emailing trendlesproject@gmail.com. In fact, my copy arrived two days after emailing them, including a small note on how to get payment to them. Very trusting! Some of the recaps which follow here have definitely benefited from refreshing my memory on the basis of the booklet.

The exhibition largely consisted of plans and even an animated reconstruction of what the site would have looked like, and these visualisations displayed next to plans made it awesome and very vivid. I can't post photos from the booklet without permission, but the book's publicly available cover image is an artist's impression of the main religious building to be found there:



As you all know, I do not relate to the past primarily through objects, and much prefer text for learning about & feeling close to antiquity (see my talk for the TECHNE 'Object in Focus' workshop on not being a visual person). But I found these really fun. Other buildings on the site included an amphitheatre. I cherish the fond but misplaced hope that in 50 years' time when I'm old we may be hosting local theatrical productions in a restored version on site! (Aim high, right?)

My main beef with viewing objects and archaeology is that it requires oodles of imagination of a kind which I don't think I have. Buried remains are not what we might imagine if we're not experts: often it's about deducing what used to be there from a shape or a trace material. For example, a square hole filled in with material different to the surrounding material, which indicates the existence of a posthole which supported a beam which would have supported some sort of built structure. Especially in the wet climes of our part of the world, materials such as the wooden posts themselves have long rotted away.

(This is why people get very excited when under exceptional circumstances (basically, anaerobic e.g. sealed off from the corrupting influence of air and all it carries, like oxygen) we do discover British organic finds, like two months ago in London. This one was particularly exciting for me personally, as one of the names attested on one of the wooden tablets was that of Julius Classicus, one of the ringleaders of the Batavian rebellion against Rome of AD69 - the Roman historian Tacitus' treatment of this revolt makes up about half of my thesis. More information on Julius Classicus can be found here, though don't believe everything you read on Wikipedia, as Classicus isn't as easily classified into Gaul or German as all that. Tacitus' representation, our only source on the rebellion and most of its protagonists, has a fluidity of identity as one of its defining features of this area and its people. The Vindolanda tablets from Hadrian's Wall are another good example.)

In that sense, the reconstructions were testimony to archaeologists' amazing skill at reading big things into little things. I'm sure it's something many people respond to incredibly enthusiastically, and when done well I can almost see what they're getting at (ha ha).

Unfortunately, however, the sorts of archaeological finds that are most easily displayable from such sites are things like coins and potsherds. Coins I find fascinating, especially if they're not random finds but found in hoards (e.g. in a container of some sorts, which was buried for reasons we will probably never know, but never recovered for reasons we will also never know but probably involve death or similarly awful things rather than forgetfulness or not caring), but again more because of the stories - here we are, words again! - behind them than as objects to look at. A report on the Roman coin finds of Marcham can be found here.

Potsherds and arrowheads and cup handles and things, however, I am not keen on, even though I'm aware that in the right hands these things can tell us massive amounts about how people lived, what they ate, where the stuff they used was made, etc. There was a bit of that in the exhibition, but I basically read the labels and then move on. The booklet, however, has close-up photographs of some of the more unusual or pretty objects founds and does a great job at explaining (in my beloved words!) why these deserve our attention. The Roman brooch with its Roman-style imagery which is nonetheless made by a native process, for example, or the slipper-shaped brooch which may mean that Mercury or a native or Romano-British hybrid god with a similar function was one of the deities worshipped there. Good stuff!

I know nothing about visitor numbers or how the exhibition was received (and the internet is proving remarkably elusive in this regard), but I hope they'll do another one in ten years or so, as I didn't get the impression archaeologists feel they've exhausted the site.

The final room in the exhibition was dedicated (of course) to dressing up as a Roman, so here's the obligatory photo of me in a sheet:

Friday, 5 February 2016

TECHNE Student Congress (January 2016, Royal Holloway)

Having spent the previous post whining about my battles with poster design and becoming a more visually aware and creative 'exhibitor', I thought I'd also write up some thoughts on the TECHNE student congress I attended during the first week of January. It's a mandatory thing organised by my funder the Arts & Humanities Research Council and the programme can be found here. Although I wasn't entirely convinced whether the programme really bore out the title of 'Digital Humanities' (I think of the sort of things Elton Barker at the Open University works on when I think of DH), it seemed to have a wide appeal. My neighbour at dinner, for example, Dane Watkins, turned out to be studying for his PhD in smart design (!) at Falmouth, which isn't part of the TECHNE consortium of institutions, but he had seen the announcement circulated and came up for it especially. (He's also got a degree in Animation, and teaches drawing, so I suddenly felt a lot more embarrassed about my poster... Nothing but kind comments, though!)

Not much there was relevant to my thesis, but it was more focused towards skills development, and had some relevant guidance on how to be the sort of academic that I might want to be: engaged in the world and with the world, through blogging, Twitter, etc. There was also some excellent stuff on the academy and politics, how to preserve our independence from government, whether to play the Big Publisher game (what alternatives there are, if any, which rely less on free extra work done by academics whilst someone else pockets the profits - I'm not sure there are any that are significantly better...)

In any case, my philosophy on conferences is rapidly changing: 40% of their significance lies in the talks (maybe 50% if you're lucky) but otherwise it's all about the people you meet during the breaks. I'm getting better at it, and it's fun! Some of the people I talked to do the most amazing-sounding projects of a creativity and (to me) 'out-there-ness' that astounds me. For example, Neil Cahoon from Roehampton: how does 'Sound Design for the Contemporary Novel: Applying the Poetics of John Cage to Digital Prose Fiction' sound to you? I'm so glad there are so many people thinking outside the box, because we need 'em. (I still struggle to make the argument for the Humanities in a convincing way in the face of policymakers who want everything quantifiable, but do find the reductio ad absurdum quite helpful: nobody wants to live in a world where no more plays get written and we all stagnate into the future supported by a cultural and intellectual canon which is no longer reinterpreted or added to.)

A word on the accommodation: the host institution for this Congress, Royal Holloway, is my home institution but of course I don't live there. To have the chance to stay over in its most iconic building, Founder's, therefore, was pretty special. I forgot to take a photo of the sunrise over the balustrades and turrets when I walked to breakfast, but here is a shot which nicely illustrates how special it was to stay in one of the bedrooms on the top floor:



It was all marvellously 'Downton servants' quarters'. Including bathroom 20 yards down the hallway, forcing an odd sort of intimacy with fellow congress-goers, passing each other by in their pyjamas on their way to the bathroom. The next ones will be at conference centres in hotels, apparently, so I'm glad I had this chance!

Thursday, 14 January 2016

"Try again, fail again, fail better"

So! I promised it would happen, and it has happened. I did yet another poster, and promised I'd say some more about it. Here it is:



The things I want to say about it are:

1. I don't like it.

2. I don't like it, firstly because I didn't have enough time to do it the way I wanted it to. This is partly because the call for posters came so late (mid-December) that it was a tall order to get something ready in time - a sentiment most people seemed to agree with as there were very few submissions in the end. But within that limited time available I also did not spend long enough planning the actual execution. Lesson learned: unlike with text when, once you have your plan or your bullet points, writing them up into real prose doesn't actually take very long, visuals require much more effort and input to take them from plan to execution.

2. How did this lack of time influence the downward spiral of this poster's design? I had in mind a vast expense of whiteness with very little text, in which my black and white hand-drawn cartoons would stand out really starkly. I was quite taken with this idea of a clean, modern, two-tone thing which would massively stand out in whatever crowd of posters would end up surrounding mine. But it turns out that when you scan cartoons drawn on white paper the background is almost grey. I think I may be able to fiddle with scanner settings and do this better, but I didn't have time then and it wasn't the only problem. Anyway, I decided that as B&W was off I'd switch to colour. At that point I panicked a little and went for a blue background and a colour scheme based on my university logo which is blue and orange. But the result looks really pedestrian and unprofessional. Wrong blue! Not enough time.

I then realised on top of that that I did not have the skills to draw, in Microsoft PowerPoint, the 'family tree' style linkages between cartoons that I wanted, possibly with a superscription for each arrow/link of one word or very concise sentence to indicate what kind of hierarchy or link we were talking about. (Something like 'why this matters' or 'to put this in context'). Nor had I allowed myself the time to look up how to do what I wanted. So I also ended up putting in more text than I wanted to.

What I think could have saved this all was to follow, after scanning the drawings, the procedure outlined on the blog I linked to in my last post. Something to do with using Inkscape to make the drawings into line-only entities separate from their background - does that make them vectors in the jargon? (Apologies, I am not a graphic person.) That wasy I could have imported them onto the white background and everything would have looked different. Not sure I have the heart/time to make yet a third version of this research strand in poster form, but the Inkscaping is a skill I really want to master.

3. My own view of this poster was a lot more negative than that of the audience looking at it at the conference.

I've never drawn so much traffic before, with a good number of people stopping to chat about both content and execution. And the intended laughs materialised too! Everyone seems agreed on the challenge of distilling ideas into very small visual or textual bites. The general sense was that having both my posters up next to one another gave people a really good insight into this strand of my research, but most people weren't sure that having just the cartoons poster alone would have given them as much, so that probably does count as a part-failure. But scholarly discussion was fostered, so not a complete one! Many more people than I expected related to the theme of abusive governments and subjects categorised by government and then treated in a certain way. People are still being labelled today according to processes against which they have very limited power to protest: refugee versus migrant was one that came up the most. Also of interest were the power structures and mechanisms which attempt to combat or, on the contrary, cement this powerlessness. In my case, Roman citizenship was one way of making sure you had some legal footing and clout to appeal to violations of your rights, though even there (my argument goes) all that goes out the window when faced with a state which doesn't want to honour these defences and elides status differences through sheer application of force. In the same way, access to modern technologies nowadays can be both liberating (think of the role of Twitter in the Arab Spring) or controlling and repressive (think of CCTV).

Thanks to Heather Isaksen for the inspiration in her own right, and for introducing me to the work of Hugleikur Dagsson.

Wednesday, 16 December 2015

Arts & Humanities research posters

So I told you all in the previous blog that I'd been inspired to start thinking about my next poster more visually, right? It seems like the time has come to put this into action, because shortly after my last blog post an email came round advertising the TECHNE Student Congress on Digital Humanities at the beginning of January, with a specific call for posters. The plan which will now be translated into a real product is to re-do my poster from the November conference via the medium of stick men cartoons. I don't yet have anything new written that I'd like to present in poster form, and in any case thought it would be an interesting experiment to give myself the chance to 'do it differently' (as one so often says after a particular event or presentation). It's all part of the learning. My inspiration comes from various quarters, but honourable mentions must go to Heather Isaksen who is an excellent lampoonist herself but on top of that got me into the work of Hugleikur Dagsson whose books often cause me to erupt into rib-aching laughter.

This was the version I presented at the end of November:



I was pleased with its content and felt I had successfully managed to isolate one strand of research in the chapter I've just finished, but deliberately kept the visuals unchallenging because in my first ever poster, at the bottom of this post, I tried to spend a lot of attention on both style and content and ended up doing both rather badly. Baby steps, I say. Now here's the storyboard which I drew hurriedly during the November conference and have added a little to since then (apologies for my lack of image editing abilities which means I wasn't able to rotate the image - it doesn't seem to be a simple HTML code but requires CSS or something):



As you can see it's roughly the same poster as version 2, but more visually appealing I hope, more humorous and more creative. Hopefully if I keep going down this route I may one day win a poster prize, as there always seems to be a competition near these things. Until I did some further research today I thought I would either draw the cartoons by hand or use MyPaint, or Microsoft Paint when I go home for Christmas and can use my parents' desktop, but I've found some great advice online here which suggests drawing by hand, scanning and then using Inkscape. It all sounds quite doable, but of course I am time-limited so I may have to stick to PowerPoint - we'll see.

Another awesome repository of information for all things research poster is a man called Colin Purrington's blog here. There's still not that much out there for the humanities specifically, and what there is seems to conform to the rules of boring loudly disparaged by these two whizzy science-based blogs, and I subscribe, at least in theory, to the idea that it's not because we may be more text-based or whatever that we need be boring and ignore the principles of good design. I probably did do that, in my first poster:



But I like to think I can learn from the experience! If this next one comes out looking nice, I may be able to use it for the next @ObjectFocus event in April which will look specifically at cartoons. Although I seem to remember it'll largely be about the materiality of this medium which has been overlooked, not their print content. But who knows. And so Christmas is starting to look a little less relaxing!